1. Home
2. Daily News
3. Lawyer convicted in fatal shooting of man…

Criminal Justice

Lawyer convicted in fatal shooting of man who attacked him in law firm parking lot

By Debra Cassens Weiss

March 10, 2025, 10:07 am CDT

A Connecticut lawyer was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter Friday for fatally shooting a man who attacked him in the parking lot of his law firm.

Robert L. Fisher Jr., 78, of Connecticut was convicted after jurors deliberated for three hours, report Law360, CT Insider and the Register Citizen.

Connecticut law imposes a “duty to retreat” before using force that can cause death or serious injury, according to the Register Citizen and a previous Connecticut Insider story. The duty applies only when a person can safely retreat and is outside the home or the office.

The state does not have a stand-your-ground law, which allows the use of deadly force without a duty to retreat, even outside the home or the workplace, when a person reasonably thinks that it is necessary to prevent death or serious injury.

The June 2021 incident began, Fisher had testified, when Matthew Bromley pulled him from his car and began punching him, claiming that the lawyer had “ruined my life,” according to CT Insider. Then Bromley spit in his face, according to Fisher’s testimony, described by CT Insider.

“I was in fear,” Fisher said. “He was so impossibly angry his face was contorted with rage. I have never seen anything like it. I undid my seat belt and kicked him, so he would be farther away. … I got out of the car to face him. … He charged me in the chest. He was shouting. ‘I am going to kill you.’”

Fisher, who was 74 years old at the time of the incident, said he fired his gun when Bromley charged toward him and reached for his arm. Prosecutors said Fisher could have retreated to his car and locked the door, rather than shoot Bromley.

Prosecutors had cited eyewitness accounts that Fisher stepped forward from his car’s open door before shooting. The forward step showed that the shooting was in revenge for the attack, rather than self-protection, the prosecution claimed.

In his closing argument, Litchfield County State’s Attorney David Shannon described what he thought that Fisher could have been thinking, according to Law360.

“How dare this little man in his beat-up old Saab, wearing his wife beater tank top and his cargo shorts, assault him?” Shannon said. “How dare he [Bromley] do that? He [Fisher] was going to refuse to be a victim. That’s what happened here.”

Write a letter to the editor, share a story tip or update, or report an error.

A 26-year-old man in Arizona has been arrested for allegedly killing his 2-year-old stepchild, beating the boy to death and explaining to authorities that the toddler was “a lot.”

Hein Lwin was taken into custody in October and is currently facing charges of premeditated first-degree murder in the child’s slaying, authorities announced.

According to a news release from the Peoria Police Department, officers at about 6:15 p.m. on Thursday, Oct. 24, responded to a call at an apartment complex in the area near 108th Avenue and Olive Avenue. The caller identified himself as Lwin and told the emergency dispatcher that his stepchild “was choking on a cloth.”

A man has been charged in the death of a 21-year-old mother killed when a bullet was fired in a crowded Massachusetts nightclub parking lot eight years ago by a suspected gang member who bragged about the killing and his associates tried to cover it up.

Henry “J.R.” Del-Rio, 27, faces the charge in the death of Ashlee Berryman. Del-Rio was indicted by a grand jury on charges including first-degree murder, assault and battery and weapons offenses.

“The conduct that Henry Del-Rio is alleged to have engaged in outside the Braza Grille was outrageous, and it ended in terrible tragedy,” Middlesex District Attorney Marian Ryan said in a statement. “Ashlee Berryman, a completely innocent victim, was caught in a hail of gunfire and lost her life.

“Those actions ripped her from her then 3-year-old son as well as her other family and friends,” she added in a Friday news conference.

In the early morning of Aug. 13, 2015, a crowd of concertgoers gathered in the parking lot outside the Braza Bar & Grill in Everett, north of Boston. Berryman had gone to the concert to see her boyfriend, one of the performers.

In that parking lot was Del-Rio with his acquaintances — all allegedly associated with the East Side Money gang, prosecutors said.

At about 12:50 a.m., two men who had not been at the concert arrived in the area and began arguing with one of Del-Rio’s associates.

After the confrontation, Del-Rio allegedly drew a .40 caliber semi-automatic pistol and fired nine times at the men, and didn’t stop firing as the men ran. He struck one of the men in the feet and ankles.

A bullet hit Berryman in the back, fatally wounding her. An Everett police officer in the area at the time heard gunshots at 12:56 a.m. and responded. Berryman was found suffering from a gunshot wound and died at a hospital.

“You just took away a 3-year-old’s mother,” Berryman’s sister, Alex Berryman, told the Boston Globe then. “Maybe you don’t have a mother, and that’s why you’re such a monster. But if you did have a mother, or if you do have a mother, imagine growing up without her.”

Bullets also lodged into a wooden municipal sign, smashed through the front window of a Rite-Aid across the street and penetrated the roof of a passing car, prosecutors said.

In the days afterward, the suspect brazenly told people he was responsible for the shot that had killed Berryman.

Investigators also learned that his associates had agreed to conceal the truth of what had happened and talked about disposing of the murder weapon, which has never been found.

“This violent, predictively tragic behavior we will not forget, and we will not cease looking to get to the results,” Ryan said.

There’s nothing surprising about what took place here. What is surprising is that more people were not hurt, given the number of times that this gun was fired in a city that is extremely densely populated.”

Del-Rio is being held in connection with a federal case and was expected to be brought to Middlesex Superior Court to be arraigned later.

He has been in federal custody since December 2022 in a separate federal gun case, details of which she said would be revealed at his arraignment.

The Globe reported he was released from custody in September 2020 after a conviction for federal drug and weapons infractions.

 

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]